The Historical Background and Current Status of the U.S. Non-OEM Collision Parts Aftermarket
Market News

The Historical Background and Current Status of the U.S. Non-OEM Collision Parts Aftermarket

The sheet metal parts, plastic parts, and lights of the car body account for the majority of car damage in car accidents. Hundreds of thousands of accidents involving damage to these parts occur every year. The repair and replacement of these parts are an important source of income for car repair shops and parts manufacturers.
Published: Dec 10, 2021
The Historical Background and Current Status of the U.S. Non-OEM Collision Parts Aftermarket

Automotive After-Sales (AS) Market

According to US insurance statistics, the original manufacturer’s car worth US$25,000 will drive a repair market of about US$100,000. In the repair of a vehicle damaged in an accident, the insurance company believes that the increased repair cost of replacing OEM parts may be close to the total price of the car, so it is better to buy a new car instead of repairing it. In some cases, using similar sub-factory parts (that is, non-OEM crash parts) can significantly reduce maintenance costs and help reduce car insurance premiums. If there is no viable market that allows the use of non-OEM replacement parts, then automakers will monopolize the replacement parts industry, and there will be no price constraints or balance. Opening the AM (after-sales) market is in the best interests of consumers and insurance companies.

The substitution of AM parts for OEM parts by American property insurers is legally regarded as a permissible practice. Car manufacturers tried to protect their market by limiting auto collision parts to OE parts through legislation, but they did not achieve it. A new strategy to protect the use of auto collision parts is to site design patents to prevent independent manufacturers from manufacturing and selling auto collision parts. Aftermarket competition using design patents to prevent auto collision parts has become a trend. In recent years, more and more car manufacturers have filed design patent infringement lawsuits with the courts to exclude aftermarket competition. In addition to the United States, they have also filed design patent infringement lawsuits for replacement parts in European and Taiwan courts.

In recent years, original manufacturers have used design patents to eliminate competition in the after-sales parts market. What are the possibilities of opening up the AM market and how to deal with it?

What Are the Auto Collision Parts for the AM Market?

AM auto collision parts are usually sheet metal parts or plastic parts and lights installed on the exterior of the car. Auto collision parts do not include mechanical parts, such as batteries, filters, silencers, shock absorbers, and engine parts.

An AM independent manufacturer refers to a manufacturer other than the original manufacturer of the part. It is also known as a non-OEM manufacturer or sub-factory.

There are three sources of auto collision parts that can usually be used to repair damaged vehicles:

  1. Original equipment manufacturing (OEM) parts are manufactured by the original car manufacturer, and they are brand new parts manufactured by the original manufacturer of the vehicle specifically to match a specific brand and model of vehicle.
  2. Non-Original Equipment Manufacturing (Non-OEM) parts, also known as aftermarket crash parts, are generic parts produced by independent manufacturers. These manufacturers produce replacement crash parts and are cheaper than original equipment manufacturers.
  3. Used, rescued, refurbished, or recycled second-hand parts are purchased from salvage companies and garbage dumps. They are usually only used to provide special insurance policies with lower premiums in exchange for the insurance company's right to use the lowest-priced auto collision parts to repair the vehicle. Most of the junkyard parts are OEM parts.

Most of the disputes in the automotive maintenance field and industry lie in the use of OEM parts and non-standard parts.

In the past few years, the use of second-hand recycled parts, salvaged from the garbage dump, has received a lot of attention. The written consent of the vehicle owner is required for the use of second-hand recycled auto collision parts for vehicle maintenance.

Usually, second-hand parts (whether metal sheet parts or car lights, etc.) that appear in the repair shop, come from old car bodies and are in poor shape. They need to be removed from the old car, have rust and contamination removed, and have paintwork redone. Often parts must be sent back until the acceptable parts are available, which will extend the repair time.

In the 1960s, before the introduction of automotive aftermarket parts, only OEM parts would be used for replacement. The sales price of replacement parts increased to seven or eight times the manufacturing cost. In the absence of common parts with similar appearance, the only substitutes for these expensive parts were second-hand parts from other wrecked vehicles. Wholesale companies were able to affect the pricing structure by limiting repairs to only using expensive OEM parts, so that everyone in the replacement parts structure got a huge profit. The car factory that repairs the body had a 40% profit margin, and the dealer who sold the part got a considerable profit. In principle, to repair a fender, the consumer had to pay 500 US dollars using an OEM part, compared to only 75 US dollars if he were to use a non-OEM part.

The development background of the non-OEM replacement parts industry. In the early 1970s, American creativity prompted some enterprising companies to manufacture similar parts in foreign regions and sell them at a fraction of the cost of OEM parts. However, these early non-OEM parts were often of uneven quality, inferior, or made of thinner or weaker materials. Many parts could not be installed properly, had flanges and fins in incorrect locations, would rattle after installation, and required a lot of work to assemble or install. Therefore, until the late 1970s, auto repair shops mainly used OEM parts for repairs.

With the popularity and cheapness of manufacturing technology, independent manufacturers began to manufacture and sell automotive replacement parts at a lower cost, which led to an average drop in the price of OEM parts by 30%. But at the same time, automakers also carried out large-scale public relations and legal activities against the use of after-sales parts, claiming that non-OEM parts were not safe and of low quality. They called non-OEM parts “imitation parts” and advised car owners to not use them. As a result, many insured car owners across the country began to rebel against insurance companies using non-OEM because they believed that the use of these parts was deceitful or would cause harm. The auto manufacturers also claimed that independent research has proven that the quality of non-OEM repair parts is low and that only the design of OEM replacement parts can meet the defined quality, safety, and appearance specifications.

Quality and CAPA certification of non-OEM replacement parts

The U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) recorded studies on non-OEM replacement parts, but the results varied. One study found that non-OEM parts were of poor quality, improperly assembled, and rust faster than OEM parts. If OEM parts are replaced during car repairs, the parts will cause greater damage in subsequent collisions, which will cause innocent dealers to fall into conflict between insurance companies, car manufacturers, state governments, and consumer rights protectors. However, other studies sponsored by the insurance industry and insurance associations determined that the quality of non-OEM parts does not affect vehicle safety.

The Automotive Certified Parts Association (CAPA) is an independent, fair, non-profit, and completely transparent organization that has no established interest in the results. It was established in 1987 and established and supervised a test plan to ensure the applicability and quality of auto parts. CAPA has become a recognized authority on the quality and safety of parts used in collision repairs in the automotive industry. To determine the quality of auto collision parts, CAPA inspects the manufacturer’s plant, equipment, manufacturing process, and final product. If the inspected parts are the same as the new OEM parts in terms of appearance, assembly, material composition, and mechanical properties, the non-OEM parts will receive CAPA certification. The CAPA quality seal certifies that replacement parts have passed CAPA certification standards, providing independent and objective quality assurance, and can be installed, executed, and used like original parts without further testing. CAPA's professional certification system can control the quality of non-OEM products. On the other hand, it can eliminate low-quality non-OEM products and suppliers. Non-OEM products can only obtain the support of insurance companies and consumers through CAPA certification.

Disputes over non-OEM parts

Repair shops like OEM parts because they fit perfectly and do not require refurbishment or adjustment. However, the repair shop usually does not have OEM parts in stock, so they must be ordered, which will extend the repair time. On the other hand, insurance companies like non-OEM parts because OEM parts are more expensive, and they usually only use OEM parts when there are no other parts available. The owner/insured is caught in the middle. Some people prefer OEM parts, while others prefer non-OEM parts, especially those who need to repair themselves.

  • Cost:
    Despite passing the CAPA certification, the prices of non-OEM parts are much cheaper than OEM parts. Automakers and those who oppose the use of non-OEM crash parts believe that the cost difference of general-purpose parts will soon be made up by the poor quality of the parts and the negative impact on the resale value of the car. However, insurance companies believe that lower maintenance costs will reduce the insurance premiums for policyholders. If non-OEM parts are not used, the high cost of OEM parts will greatly increase insurance costs.
  • Safety:
    Generally, insurance companies believe that after-sales parts are only exterior decorations of the car body and will not affect the safety of the vehicle. However, automakers believe that non-OEM parts cannot fit or fit in the same way, which may cause unsafe driving. There is no clear conclusion on the safety of non-OEM parts. However, many non-OEM products have passed CAPA certification, and from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) research, it can be found that non-OEM parts will not affect the safety of the vehicle.
  • Warranty:
    For the use of non-OEM parts, guarantees have always been an important part of the dispute. The question is whether the use of non-OEM parts will affect the guarantee of the entire vehicle. Those who oppose the use of non-OEM parts believe that the use of non-OEM parts to repair damaged vehicles will invalidate the manufacturer’s warranty. This argument is unreasonable. MMWA (The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act) stipulates that any guarantor can stipulate the continuous validity of the guarantee, and is limited to the use of authorized repair services or authorized replacement parts for non-guaranteed services and maintenance. MMWA can prevent manufacturers from invalidating the warranty based on the use of aftermarket non-OEM parts or recycled original OEM parts during maintenance. Its purpose is to improve the adequacy of information available to consumers, prevent fraud, and improve competition in consumer product marketing.

Taiwan’s auto parts exports are still mainly to the United States, and it has maintained a market share of about 40% in the U.S. market. Taiwan’s auto parts manufacturers do not necessarily have to manufacture OEM parts. Independent manufacturers of non-OEM parts want a place in the AM market. They must find ways to save themselves and think about how to use the IPR or PGR procedures in the patent system to strike the validity of design patents of original parts, or obtain the original manufacturer's patent authorization.

On the other hand, you can use the searched previous technology or the original design patent applications of auto collision parts to analyze the scope of patent protection or limit the scope of patent rights, and prepare to make good use of it in infringement litigation in the future. In addition, if independent manufacturers have considerable development capabilities, they can find a patent firm or attorney who is familiar and proficient in design patents to help analyze the scope of protection of design patents, to find avoidable design spaces, and research and design enough avoidance design into the scope of protection.

Published: Dec 10, 2021 Source :naipo

Further reading

You might also be interested in ...

Headline
Market News
UAV Market and Technology Development Trend
The drone is small in size and can be equipped with various modules. Its application feature is that it can replace people to perform dirty, dull, and dangerous tasks. In addition to improving the execution efficiency, it can also reduce the risk of operators, so it can expand Various application market advantages.
Headline
Market News
Opportunities and Challenges of China's Intellectual Property Service Industry
The rapid development of science and technology innovation, the rise of the knowledge economy, the acceleration of economic globalization and informatization, the creation, utilization, and protection of intellectual property rights have become important factors in promoting national economic development. Many countries are implementing or starting to formulate development strategies related to intellectual property rights to enhance the country's competitiveness in international economic and trade activities.
Headline
Market News
Wisdom Upgrade, China Machine Tools are Actively Transforming
In 2020, the global machine tool market is worth 111.36 billion U.S. dollars. Affected by the COVID-19 epidemic and the Sino-US trade war, China’s import and export value of machine tools will decline by 17.7% and 11.5% respectively in 2020 compared to 2019. However, it is still the world’s largest machine tool market, accounting for approximately the world’s total 35%.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in Spain
The Spanish government promotes bicycle culture and spares no effort. The rapid growth of bicycle users has also led to the growth of related enterprises in the bicycle industry. Among them, electric bicycles are the most popular, with sales increasing by 63.6% and sales of more than 40,000 units.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in France
The France sports climate is booming. More than 58% of residents of the Greater Paris area exercise at least once a week for at least 30 minutes each time. Among them, indoor sports such as yoga or Pilates accounted for 13%, the largest proportion, followed by walking 12%, jogging 8%, swimming, cycling, muscle training, and other sports enthusiasts. Paris has ample public space, people can exercise without spending money, but there are also various specialized paid fitness centers in the city.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in Canada
The COVID-19 epidemic has changed the exercise habits of Canadians, driving the upsurge of home fitness and outdoor sports. Business opportunities for home fitness equipment and outdoor sports products have emerged, including home fitness equipment, bicycles, golf, camping, skiing products, and other hot products, online sales growth is even more amazing. The sports climate in Canada is prosperous, chain fitness channels are expanding rapidly, various sports equipment and supplies are in great demand, and the products are more diversified.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in the United States
In 2019, the overall North American sports market revenue is approximately US$73 billion, making it one of the largest sports markets in the world. It is expected to grow to US$83.1 billion by 2023. Nowadays, the sports market is growing rapidly. In the past few decades, it has become a mature industry in the world.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in Australia
The top five sports most loved by Australians, including walking, gymnasium (containing oxygen dance), jogging and running, swimming and diving, cycling, and cycling, have also changed as a result, resulting in new sports trends under the epidemic Goods with fever.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in Korea
Affected by the COVID-19 epidemic, the total sales of the sports goods market from February to June 2020 was 837.8 billion won, a 40% decrease compared to the same period in 2019, and the number of private sports industry companies also decreased by 28.6%, 2020 South Korea’s overall sports market was a year of decline.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in Japan
Since 2019, Japan has hosted international sports events such as the World Rugby Games and the Tokyo Olympics, which indirectly sparked an upsurge in sports and fitness for all age groups. According to a survey report on the Japanese sports market, the size of the sports market in 2019 was ¥2250.4 billion.
Headline
Market News
The Development Trend of the Sports Industry in China
China's sports market continues to grow. The total market size in 2019 reached RMB 2.95 trillion, an annual growth rate of 10.9%. Among them, the sports service market reached 1,493-billion-yuan, accounting for 50.6%, and the sports goods market reached 1,361.4-billion-yuan, accounting for 46.2%. The China sports market will continue to expand at an accelerated pace in the next few years. By 2025, the scale of China's sports market will exceed 5 trillion yuan, and through 5G, Internet of Things, big data, and artificial intelligence technologies, boring exercises will be transformed into leisure activities.
Headline
Market News
Analysis and Outlook of the Global Motorcycle and Scooter Market
The Asian region has always been the core area for global motorcycle and scooter sales, with India, China, and Indonesia being the top three markets. The Asian market has potential. The global demand for motorcycles and scooters is increasing.
Agree