The Biggest Difficulty in Carbon Reduction in the Supply Chain
Market News

The Biggest Difficulty in Carbon Reduction in the Supply Chain

Supply chain carbon emissions are 11.4 times greater than operational carbon emissions. Therefore, if companies are to move towards net zero, the effectiveness of supply chain carbon reduction will be an important key. However, supply carbon reduction faces two major problems: inconsistent calculation methods and low data transparency.
Published: Oct 13, 2022
The Biggest Difficulty in Carbon Reduction in the Supply Chain

Supply chain carbon emissions are 11.4 times greater than operational carbon emissions. Therefore, if companies are to move towards net zero, the effectiveness of supply chain carbon reduction will be an important key. However, there are two major challenges in supply decarbonization, inconsistent calculation methods, and low data transparency. Why is carbon emission calculation easy to get stuck? How to solve it?

Who Can Say About Carbon Data?

At present, companies are doing carbon management, whether it is to follow ISO 14064 for the calculation of organizational carbon emissions, or to evaluate the carbon footprint of products, they all need to face the situation of asking for carbon emissions data from the upstream supply chain. For example, if the most downstream notebook computer brands want to calculate the carbon footprint of notebook computers, they need to ask dozens or hundreds of upstream suppliers of plastics, batteries, panels and other upstream suppliers for carbon emission data of the raw material manufacturing process, and These data are passed down layer by layer.

When upstream and downstream carbon data are difficult to obtain, many companies simply do not calculate the carbon footprint of their products, or only disclose a few available data. In addition, the correctness of the data provided by the supplier is also a big question, for example: whether the data has been verified by a third party.

Three Problems in Carbon Emissions Calculation

The current difficulties faced by supply chain carbon emissions calculation can be summarized into the following three reasons:

The Credibility of Carbon Data Is Doubtful:

Inconsistent calculation methods and inconsistency in database sources result in a reduction in the credibility of carbon data. In terms of calculation methods, when companies disclose upstream supply chain data, they may follow physical basis (calculated based on the carbon emission coefficient of the unit weight of raw materials), economic basis (calculated based on the carbon emission coefficient of the unit price of raw materials), and mixed methods. (Supplier data is matched with database data), or suppliers directly provide accurate carbon emission information for calculation. Different calculation methods may cause differences in calculation results, and it is difficult to ensure the consistency of results.

Inconsistent database sources, resulting in different emission coefficients, will also lead to different results. At present, there are quite a few databases to choose from in terms of international and domestic emission coefficients (such as: Environmental Protection Agency carbon footprint database, ITRI DoITPro database, Swiss Ecoinvent database, etc.), and different companies may use their own inventory experience. Or the data calculation logic is different, and the respective databases are used as the calculation basis, which eventually leads to inconsistent calculation results.

Difficult To Strike a Balance Between Commercial Confidentiality and Transparent Disclosure of Carbon Data:

The acquisition of carbon data needs to face the protectionism of various enterprises, and the acquisition of carbon emission data in the supply chain is even a gray area. How to improve the transparency of data sharing and solve the dilemma of commercial confidentiality risks is a common problem for enterprises.

Suppliers and brands may even stand on opposite sides. For suppliers, when brands require detailed carbon information, they may be less willing to provide them. But for downstream brands, the more detailed the information provided to me by the upstream, the more it can help me improve the transparency and accuracy of the information, and it can help me set the overall carbon emission management goals for the company in the future. Therefore, the balance in the middle depends on a requirement of consistency. In addition, brand owners and suppliers are concerned about the confidentiality of data. The two parties share process-related information, and how to ensure that confidentiality is not leaked is also a big problem.

The Systems are Incompatible and the Cost of Data Exchange is High:

Supply chains often span multiple stakeholders from different industries and regions, so there is a high cost of exchanging information. How to improve the interoperability of the data exchange process, including system docking and format structure compatibility, is very important.

For example, today the supplier provides raw materials to brand A and brand B at the same time, but the information format and quality required by the two companies are very different, which may cause trouble for the supplier. Therefore, in terms of the same industry chain, if the upstream, middle and downstream can reach a consensus on the data sharing structure, it should be able to shorten the data sharing communication time and speed up the efficiency of information provision.

Jointly Expose Primary Carbon Data from Upstream to Downstream, and Master the Carbon Footprint of Final Products

Based on carbon data sharing, data exchange should cover five aspects: general information, boundary description, data collection, quality and exchange, distribution principles, and presentation of carbon footprint results.

Each aspect has its own elements that should be disclosed. For example, in data collection, quality and exchange, enterprises should explain the use ratio of primary data, primary and secondary data sources, time range for primary and secondary data collection, and time representative of data collection.

In addition, compared with general brand owners who only ask them to provide carbon footprint calculation methods and results when they ask for the upstream supply chain, this standard encourages companies to use primary data, so it puts more emphasis on disclosing the primary data sharing ratio (Primary Data Share, PDS) to make carbon footprint calculation more accurate.

Under the global climate of carbon reduction, large upstream supply chain manufacturers have begun to require downstream supply chains to provide carbon inventory data. However, the lack of traces is a source of carbon anxiety for small and medium-sized enterprises. The supply chain is involved in the whole body, and the carbon data of each supplier will affect the setting of carbon reduction goals and results verification of the overall supply chain in the future.

Published by Oct 13, 2022 Source :Business Next

Further reading

You might also be interested in ...

Headline
Market News
Functional Textiles in the World of Wearable Technology
The word "function" originates from Japan, so it is understandable that functional textiles began in various chemical fiber factories in Japan. In the early days, it was emphasized that new materials produce new functions, often first with relevant fiber function technologies, and then looking for new functional applications. What is the "functionality" of textiles? The most incisive "functional" design is multi-faceted. Functions are related to people themselves and their living environment, including comfortable and healthy functions, leisure and sports functions, safety and protection functions. Contains medical and physiological functions.
Headline
Market News
The Primary Challenge of Carbon Reduction in Supply Chains
Supply chain carbon emissions are 11.4 times greater than operational carbon emissions. Therefore, if companies are to move towards net zero, the effectiveness of supply chain carbon reduction will be an important key. However, supply carbon reduction faces two major problems: inconsistent calculation methods and low data transparency.
Headline
Market News
Understanding the Concept of Net Zero Emissions
With the pressure of international net-zero emissions and the clarion call for carbon tariffs in Europe and the United States, countries have formulated relevant policies to devote themselves to energy conservation and carbon reduction.
Headline
Market News
Display Equipment Market: Global Overview and Industry Development Trends
In response to the COVID-19 epidemic, various countries have issued a series of bans, city closures and traffic restrictions, driving the demand for housing, working at home, online shopping, and home entertainment. This in turn has driven the demand for 3C products such as information and communications products. Among these, display panels have shown one of the greatest increases in demand, and the global display screen equipment market grew by 19% in 2020, reaching USD 13.52 billion.
Headline
Market News
Analysis of Global Pneumatic Tool Industry Market
With the development of weapons, machinery, and chemical industries, pneumatic tools have been widely used and developed.
Headline
Market News
Automotive Component Supply Chain
A hidden important market in the automotive supply chain is the automotive after market (AM) which is used to satisfy after-sales repairs, inspections, maintenance, replacement, or modification services, and is an important part of the automotive supply chain.
Headline
Market News
Industry Development of Garment and Apparel Manufacturing in Taiwan
The textile industry was a leading sector in Taiwan's early industrialization stage. The growth and achievements of the textile industry also led to the development of other industrial sectors. The garment manufacturing industries are downstream industries in the textile industry chain. Its upstream includes fiber manufacturing, chemical additives, spinning, weaving, dyeing and finishing, and other industries. The garment manufacturing industry are the processing stage in the industry chain. It is also an important industry that gives added value to textiles.
Headline
Market News
Opportunity Analysis and Industry Forecast of Industrial Valves
The global industrial valve market will reach 85.6 billion U.S. dollars in 2022. From the perspective of product technology leadership, European countries, especially Germany, and the United States, are the main leaders, followed by Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, China and India.
Headline
Market News
About Transportation and Warehousing Industry
With the soaring volume of e-commerce transactions, the demand for logistics is also rising. In the process of industry transformation and upgrading, smart technology has become one of the keys to industry development.
Headline
Market News
Global Market and Industry Trends of Display Equipment
In response to the COVID-19 epidemic, various countries have issued a series of bans, city closures and traffic restrictions, driving the demand for housing, working at home, online shopping, and home entertainment. This in turn has driven the demand for 3C products such as information and communications products. Among these, display panels have shown one of the greatest increases in demand, and the global display screen equipment market grew by 19% in 2020, reaching USD 13.52 billion.
Headline
Market News
3D Printing Makes A New Point for Manufacturing In Silicon Valley
3D printing technology has been widely used in recent years, and it has also allowed the manufacturing industry to evolve into a "smart" manufacturing industry, which can achieve the large output value with the less manpower.
Headline
Market News
Commercial Camera Drones Fly You Over Various Commercial Applications
How to apply camera drones in the commercial field? What are the key technologies of camera drones? This article discusses the application and technology development trend of camera drones in the commercial applications.
Agree