What is a Non-Practicing Patent Entity (NPE)?
Knowledge

What is a Non-Practicing Patent Entity (NPE)?

Non-Practicing Entities (NPEs) is a special group of the intellectual property industry. Patent litigation involving NPEs has become a common global business activity, and it is a patent issue that the technology industry needs to pay special attention to.
Published: Jun 13, 2022
What is a Non-Practicing Patent Entity (NPE)?

What is a NPE?

A Non-Practicing Entity (NPE) is an entity that has an interest in or ownership of intellectual property (IP) rights, but is not actually producing products related to this IP, nor engaging in any research and development of the IP. There are two main types of NPEs: The first is universities and research institutions which mainly conduct basic research and authorize the research results to be used by other individuals or organizations. These institutions do not engage in any commodity production.

The second is entities that acquire patent rights from individuals or small and medium-sized organizations and then use these patents to collects licensing fees from potential or alleged patent infringers. Such NPEs do not conduct any research and development activities, nor do they engage in commercialization activities or develop new technologies for the patents they own. Instead, they wait for the manufacturer of the commodity to make an irreversible huge investment, and then make a patent infringement claim against the manufacturer of the commodity.

Dou to the potential negative activities some NPEs engage in, and because they do not actually produce anything new, some NPEs may end up being referred to as patent trolls.

Overview of NPT:

Patent litigation initiated by NPEs has averaged about 30% of all patent litigation over the past 10 years. However, NPE litigation has increased significantly over the past few years, with 42% of new patent litigation filed in 2020 being filed by NPEs. This indicates a growing threat to businesses.

Defensive NPEs play a positive role in the patent intermediary market. Purchasing patent rights and licensing members who pay licensing fees, not only increases the value of patents but also protects patent holders from facing litigation costs.

Any company that manufactures, sells, or uses technology-based products and services faces a real risk of being sued for patent infringement. More than 25,000 companies have been sued for infringement since 2010, and the number of companies at risk is growing, costing billions of dollars in legal fees each year.

Most NPEs apply intellectual property rights rationally, which not only gives them considerable economic returns but also encourages business organizations to improve their innovation capabilities. However, some institutions and individuals use NPEs to adopt aggressive and frivolous intellectual property litigation tactics. By harassing companies with litigation, they discourage innovation, contrary to the original intention of intellectual property law, which is to nurture and encourage innovation.

Non-Practicing Entities which own patent rights, but do not engage in the manufacturing of goods, but instead, collect royalties or initiate patent litigation against companies that infringe its patent rights fall into the category of patent trolls.

What are the Types of NPE?

NPEs can be divided into four types: research, attack, defense, and consulting management services.

  1. R&D-oriented entities:
    • Non-profit academic research institutions perform research and development to drive technological innovation, but do not apply for patents.
    • Large-scale manufacturing enterprises conduct research and development and patent the results for production of products.
  2. Offensive patent aggregation (OPA):
    • OPA is the purchasing of patents in order to grant licenses to companies that will produce the products and inventions protected by these patents. OPAs obtain their revenue from the licensing fees collected from these patents.
  3. Defensive patent aggregation (DPA):
    • This is the practice of a manufacturer purchasing patents or patent rights from other entities holding patents similar to or related to the companies’ own patents. By purchasing threatening patents, it provides manufacturers with an insurance system to protect themselves from being sued by the owners of such patents or patent trolls.
  4. Patent management service company:
    • Assessing the technology and value of a given patent generally requires a fair amount of technical knowledge. Patent management companies help companies obtain and maintain patents, as well as provide legal and business advice for licensing and selling patents. Proactive patent management can help companies avoid litigation risks.

How to Distinguish an NPE?

To distinguish whether an NPE is reasonably engaged in patent operation activities or is acting as a so-called patent troll, the following factors can be considered. A patent troll use any of the following tactics:

  • Introduce multiple, frivolous, or abusive prosecution, such as filing claims without conducting sufficient investigation of the infringement facts and evidence before the prosecution, or launching many lawsuits against multiple companies in a short period of time.
  • They will use low-quality patents which have no practical value or do not contribute to the prior art used in the litigation.
  • The patents used in the lawsuit are not supported by rigorous R&D investments. Unlike patents used by NPEs that operate reasonably, patent trolls will not invest in actual R&D, but will apply for patents that are drawn up through simple brainstorming or imagining, but not actually produced or tested.
  • Patent trolls will not negotiate a patent license before introducing a lawsuit. They know that the patent assets they hold are not valuable, so instead of negotiating a license, they will directly sue for extortion.
  • The prosecution initiated by a patent troll has caused great trouble to the respondent and caused a chilling effect to production. For example, lawsuits are used that could create large legal costs to the respondent, which makes the respondent tend to pay for a settlement rather than defend the lawsuit.

NPEs and the General Technology Industry Have Gradually Formed a Cooperative Relationship

NPEs will try to stockpile patent ammunition necessary for litigation, often purchasing patents from technology companies. These NPEs will use these patents to file lawsuits against other technology companies in the industry. Why are the two now developing a partnerships for patent transactions?

Due to the low cost of capital in the market, NPE's pockets are getting deeper and deeper. In addition to being able to finance complicated and lengthy patent litigation procedures, they can also more carefully select the patents to be purchased. From the perspective of NPE, the absolute standard for measuring patent assets is liquidity through litigation or licensing. Patents obtained by for-profit enterprises are naturally more beneficial than those of R&D institutions or universities, so are more favored.

According to experience, when companies encounter a financial crisis, such as caused by the global epidemic, to maintain and enhance the company’s cash account, they may start to actively sell the patents they hold, some of which will inevitably flow to NPEs.

However, aside from financial considerations, timely reviewing of patent inventories can also help technology companies deploy the technology. Of course, every technology company has a system for patent management, but if they only use internal personnel, there will inevitably be blind spots. The introduction of external NPEs can often benefit the company. NPEs can be more informed and selective when purchasing patents. If the content of the invention is not relevant to the market, or the technical protection is not strict enough to prevail in litigation, the patents obtained by the company will be of little value. All of these are points companies need to consider while conducting research and development and patent applications.

After being evaluated by an NPE, some patents may be found highly valuable and easy to market, while others may be unmarketable and fail to be traded. Although the former can bring immediate benefits to the company, if the latter is truly incapable of monetization, the patentee can also consider giving up these patents to save high maintenance costs. In other words, knowing when to either keep or get rid of a patent can create value for the company. Companies can then invest in new R&D and patent activities to strengthen their technological competitiveness.

In conclusion, an enterprise's patent management strategy should be flexible. Although many technology companies have been actively trying various modes of communication about patents, most companies still only stay at the level of Apply and Hold for patents. After the patents are certified, they are simply put on the shelf. In the long run, not only will the cost of patent maintenance be higher and higher, but potential benefits to the enterprise will be lost. Therefore, reviewing the quality of their patents through negotiation and cooperation with NPEs, and further developing R&D is an operational strategy that all technology industry manufacturers should consider.

Published by Jun 13, 2022 Source :naipo

Further reading

You might also be interested in ...

Headline
Knowledge
Pressure Storage Tanks for RO Filter Systems
Reverse Osmosis (RO) filter systems have revolutionized water purification by removing contaminants at the molecular level, thereby providing high-quality drinking water. However, RO filtration is a slow process and cannot deliver immediate high-flow water like standard filtration methods. Without a storage tank, an RO system would require several minutes to fill just a single glass of water. Relying solely on direct filtration would be impractical for everyday use. To address this issue, RO filter systems employ a pressure storage tank that accumulates purified water, keeping it under a moderate pressure, sufficient to make it ready for immediate and convenient dispensing. These tanks have become an essential component of RO systems in residential, commercial, and industrial settings.
Headline
Knowledge
Benefits and Applications of Garden Rakes and Hoes
Garden rakes and hoes are indispensable tools for both professional landscapers and home gardeners. They have been used for centuries to cultivate, maintain, and enhance soil conditions, ensuring that gardens thrive. Their versatility and effectiveness make them essential for various gardening and landscaping tasks, including: Soil Preparation: Loosening compacted soil for better aeration and water penetration. Weed Control: Removing unwanted plants efficiently without using chemicals. Debris Removal: Clearing leaves, twigs, and other organic matter from garden beds and lawns. Leveling and Smoothing: Ensuring even distribution of soil, mulch, or compost. Furrowing and Planting: Creating uniform rows for planting seeds and seedlings.
Headline
Knowledge
RO Filter System Booster Pumps and Why a Diaphragm Pump Is the Best Choice
If you're considering purchasing a reverse osmosis (RO) water filtration system, you may have noticed that some models include a booster pump while others do not. If you’re unfamiliar with the technology, you might wonder: Why does an RO system need a pump? The short answer is that water pressure is crucial for efficient RO filtration, and a booster pump improves this system efficiency. So, you may then wonder, what does a diaphragm pump do, and why is it considered the best choice for RO filtration? Let’s examine why a diaphragm pump is the most reliable and effective type of pump for this application.
Headline
Knowledge
Garden Shovels: The Essential Tool for Every Gardener
Gardening has long been a rewarding hobby, as well as an essential practice for providing food, beauty, and practical benefits for any home or other environment. As gardening techniques evolved, so did the need for specialized tools, and among these, the garden shovel became an indispensable tool. There are a variety of garden shovels and trowels available, and it is interesting to note that gardeners can be quite particular when it comes to choosing their favorite hand trowel or shovel.
Headline
Knowledge
Grass Shears: Precision Cutting for Lawn Care
Grass shears have long been recognized as an effective solution for trimming grass in areas where traditional lawnmowers cannot reach. They offer precision cutting, allowing gardeners and landscapers to maintain clean, well-defined edges along pathways, garden beds, and other landscaping features. Advances in materials and design have improved their efficiency, durability, and ease of use.
Headline
Knowledge
Hedge Shears: Essential Tools for Precision Gardening
A good pair of hedge shears can easily transform unruly bushes into beautifully manicured landscapes. Hedge shears have been a staple tool in both amateur and professional gardening for decades, providing a practical solution for shaping and controlling plant growth, transforming unruly hedges into neat, visually appealing landscapes.
Headline
Knowledge
Introduction to Tree Pruners
Tree pruners, often referred to as pole pruners or tree trimmers, have been recognized as an ideal solution for maintaining and managing tree growth in both urban and rural landscapes. These tools facilitate the safe and efficient pruning of branches that are otherwise difficult and hazardous to reach. By enabling users to trim trees from the ground without the aid of ladders or climbing equipment, tree pruners help avoid the risks associated with traditional tree trimming methods.
Headline
Knowledge
Comparing Coffee Grinders: Blade, Burr, Hand, and Electric
For coffee enthusiasts seeking to brew the perfect cup, one of the key elements in achieving consistent flavor is the grind. Choosing the right grinder is essential to achieve the proper grind size for the brewing method used. Consistency in the grind directly influences the brewing process and, ultimately, the flavor of the coffee.
Headline
Knowledge
Gooseneck Coffee Water Brewing Kettles: A Quality Coffee Experience
Brewing the perfect cup of coffee requires more than just premium beans and a skilled barista—it starts with water. Coffee water brewing kettles are an innovative solution to the challenge of controlling water quality, temperature, and flow rate, all of which significantly affect the flavor and aroma of brewed coffee. These kettles are now a staple for coffee aficionados and professionals alike, offering precision and consistency in every cup.
Headline
Knowledge
Steel Cables for Bicycle and Car Brake Systems
Steel cables are an integral component of mechanical systems that demand precise and reliable motion transfer. This is particularly vital in the brake systems of both bicycles and automobiles, where safety and efficiency are paramount. The core purpose of steel cables in these systems is to transmit physical force effectively to the braking mechanism, facilitating immediate and controlled deceleration.
Headline
Knowledge
Choosing the Best Forklift for Your Warehouse: A Guide for New Managers
Forklifts are essential tools for any warehouse, facilitating the efficient movement of goods and materials. Selecting the right forklift requires understanding their history, technology, and applications.
Headline
Knowledge
A Barista’s Guide to French Press Coffee Makers
The French Press coffee maker, celebrated for its simplicity and its ability to create rich, aromatic coffee, is a staple in coffee brewing. For baristas and coffee enthusiasts alike, understanding the history, design, and versatility of French Press coffee makers is key to appreciating their value and mastering their use.
Agree