Why Blockchain Does Not Guarantee Decentralization, Immutability, or Trust
Market News

Why Blockchain Does Not Guarantee Decentralization, Immutability, or Trust

The "decentralization" of the blockchain has many advantages, but it does not mention its shortcomings. In fact, "decentralization" and "centralization" have their own advantages and disadvantages, so "using both" is a more feasible way, why?
Published: Dec 25, 2024
Why Blockchain Does Not Guarantee Decentralization, Immutability, or Trust

Blockchain has the characteristics of decentralization, immutability, and trustworthiness. Many people keep touting the advantages of blockchain "decentralization", but do not mention its shortcomings. "Centralization" has its own advantages and disadvantages, so "using both" is a more feasible way, why?

Most Applications of Public Chains are Cryptocurrencies

A blockchain that anyone can build and participate in is called "Public blockchain". Anyone can read, send, and confirm transaction data and participate in the consensus process, which is usually considered a "decentralized" blockchain. blockchain. For example: Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc. At present, most of the applications of the public chain are cryptocurrencies. Since there is a large market for underground finance, unless the government prohibits it, it will continue to operate.

The miners of the public chain do not know each other, and are unlikely to collude to tamper with the data of the blockchain, so it satisfies "decentralization"; if the public chain uses mining operations, it can satisfy "non-tampering"; although the public chain cannot be tampered, but it does not mean that it can be trusted. A database can be trusted. Two conditions must be met: first verify that the data is correct, and then confirm that it cannot be tampered with after writing to the database. The public chain can only meet the second condition, but cannot meet the first condition, so the public chain "may not" be trusted.

The Consortium Blockchain is Suitable for Application in Various Business Models

The blockchain established and participated by multiple specific enterprises or organizations is called "Consortium Blockchain", which is suitable for use in transactions, settlements, clearing and other work between institutions, so that specific institutions can trust each other. Since the participants of the alliance chain have a high degree of trust after screening, it is not necessary to use the energy-wasting mining operation like Bitcoin, and can use "Practical Byzantine" instead. Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT: Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance)” or other algorithms to improve efficiency, coupled with a small number of nodes, so the transaction speed is faster, suitable for various business models.

However, we must pay special attention to the fact that the consortium blockchain is still divided into true and false. "True Consortium Blockchain" means that the members of the alliance are completely independent and equal to each other, and no one member can dominate the other members, the participants are all large enterprises; "Fake Consortium Blockchain" means that members are closely related to each other, which may be branches, subsidiaries, and related enterprises. One parent company can control more than 51% of the node, if violates the 51% rule, the blockchain will lose its effectiveness. The blockchains currently used by many companies belong to the "Fake Consortium Blockchain", so be careful when judging.

The members of the true consortium blockchain are completely independent and equal to each other, and are unlikely to collude and tamper with the data of the blockchain, so it satisfies the "decentralization"; the true consortium blockchain can use the Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT) algorithm and therefore satisfy the "Impossible" "Falsification"; although the real consortium blockchain cannot be tampered with, it does not mean that it can be trusted, so the true consortium blockchain "may not" be trusted; the members of the fake consortium blockchain are closely related to each other, and may collude to tamper with the information of the blockchain, so there is no "Decentralization"; the fake consortium blockchain has a parent company that can control more than 51% of the nodes, if violates the 51% rule, there is no "non-tampering"; since the fake consortium blockchain is not immutable, of course, there is no "trustworthy".

Private Chains are Useless

A blockchain established by a single enterprise or organization is called a "Private Blockchain". Only specific people can read, send, and confirm transaction data, participate in the consensus process, and can be manipulated and modified to transform the original simple data structure. Makes it complicated and totally violates the 51% rule, so it's useless.

The private chain is established by a single enterprise or organization, which may tamper with the data of the blockchain, so there is no “decentralization”; because the private chain is established by a single enterprise or organization that controls more than 51% of the nodes, if violates the 51% rule, so there is no “unable to”. Tampering"; since there is no private chain that cannot be tampered with, of course there is no "trustworthy".

Why Does Blockchain Not Mean "Decentralization"?

When many people hear the "chain" of the block, they think it is a special technology to "chain" many computers. In fact, the block is a passbook, and the blockchain is a passbook chain (many passbooks), so the block chain is just a record. The data structure of the data is just the data structure. The algorithm ensures that the transaction records cannot be tampered with. At the same time, it is copied in many copies and stored in the computers of many miners. Of course, it can also be stored in only one computer. If we put the blockchain (passbook chain) stored in a computer, how can it be considered "decentralized"? Many articles mention the blockchain, and the first feature is decentralization. This is a wrong concept. It should be said that the blockchain can (but not necessarily) be decentralized.

"Public chain" is currently the only blockchain that is recognized as "more in line with" the conditions of decentralization; whether the "consortium blockchain" is decentralized or not, it must be confirmed whether it is true or false. If it is a true consortium blockchain, it is in line with decentralization. If the chain has a parent company that can control more than 51% of the nodes, it is not in line with decentralization; as for the "private chain" established by a single enterprise or organization, it is completely centralized.

Some people may wonder why the public chain is "more in line with" decentralization, rather than "completely in line with" decentralization, this is because as long as someone masters more than 51% of the computing power, it is still possible to manipulate the public chain, for example: Bitcoin There are more than 10,000 miners scattered all over the world. At first glance, they are decentralized. In fact, mining is based on the computing power of mining machines. At present, more than 51% of the computing power is controlled by some world-renowned mining companies. In the hands of the company, it is true that there have been experts who have questioned whether Bitcoin can be trusted.

Why Does Blockchain Not Mean "Immutable"?

The blockchain is just a data structure for recording data. The algorithm ensures that the transaction records cannot be tampered with, but this can only be established in the "public chain", because there are more than 10,000 miners in Bitcoin, and more than 10,000 people are required to conspire to tamper with it. The Bitcoin blockchain is very difficult; whether the "consortium blockchain" cannot be tampered with must be confirmed. If it is a true consortium blockchain, it is incompatible with tampering. If it is a fake consortium blockchain, there is a parent company that can control more than 51% of the nodes, then this the blockchain can be tampered with; as for the "private chain" established by a single enterprise or organization, it can be tampered with any way you want, and even algorithms can't prevent it!

Why Does Blockchain Not Mean "Trustworthy"?

The blockchain is just a data structure for recording data. The algorithm ensures that transaction records cannot be tampered with. Therefore, some people call it a "Trust Machine", but it does not mean "trustworthy". A database can be trusted, and two conditions must be met: first verify that the data is correct, and then confirm that it cannot be tampered with after writing to the database. The blockchain can't help the first condition at all, it can only satisfy the second condition, and it must be a public chain or a true consortium blockchain. If it is a fake consortium blockchain or a private chain, even the second condition cannot be fulfilled. More importantly, usually the database is fake, most of it is not because someone has tampered with it afterwards, but because the information written in the beginning is fake!

Blockchain is Definitely Not A "Trust Machine"

Our world is built on trust mechanisms, for example: we hand over our personal property to banks for safekeeping, which is based on trust in the financial system; we hand over personal information to the government for safekeeping, which is based on trust in government institutions, many people keep advocating that the old trust mechanism is insufficient for protection. For example, everyone completely relies on a third-party trust agency to provide proof of value and proof of ownership. What if the third-party trust agency is fraudulent? And the old proof method has many shortcomings, including: not easy to pass, easy to forge, inefficiency, regulatory restrictions and so on.

Therefore, the blockchain must be used as a trust machine, because the blockchain can encrypt and protect the shared ledger to ensure that the data cannot be tampered with. The decentralization of the blockchain does not need to rely on third-party trust agencies. innovative applications, these are completely misleading claims.

In fact, the use of blockchain does not solve the problem of insufficient protection of the old trust mechanism. What the "public chain" and "true consortium blockchain" in the blockchain can achieve is "decentralization" and "immutability". Relying on blockchain technology cannot be trusted, and in the end, it must rely on a third-party trust organization to be trusted, just like the old trust mechanism.

Byzantine Algorithm!? Why is Blockchain So Complicated?

If Bitcoin or blockchain wants to be designed to be completely decentralized, it must have "clear rules and strict organization". This is the biggest difficulty of blockchain at present. Therefore, strict communication rules must be formulated. No matter how it is designed, there will still be some loopholes, which is why it is said that some problems are solved with the blockchain, but some problems are created.

What Can Be Done to Increase the Operational Efficiency of the Blockchain?

The easiest way is to change the algorithm not to mine, such as using "Proof of Stake (PoS)"; you can also change the data structure or operating rules of the blockchain, such as: Bitcoin Cash (BCH), Bitcoin Gold (BTG) and Bitcoin Diamond (BCD) are new cryptocurrencies derived from Bitcoin's "Hard fork", but these methods have limited effect.

The most effective way is to try to make it more "centralized", for example: every transaction between members in the exchange is stored in the exchange's computer (centralized), when someone wants to send bitcoins to another exchange or private account, and then write it into the miner's computer (decentralized), so that tens of thousands of bitcoin transactions can be made every second.

In addition, some cryptocurrencies try to cut the blockchain that was originally scattered in the computers of more than 10,000 miners around the world into 10 different "sub-blockchains", but doing so is actually using partial "centralization" to replace “decentralization”. Speaking of which, it is a matter of fish and bear’s paw to be completely decentralized and efficient.

Blockchains using the above new methods are currently being researched and developed, but they also have their own problems. So far, there is no real perfect method. What is certain is that both "decentralization" and "centralization" are each has its own advantages and disadvantages, so "decentralization" is not a panacea, and "using both" is a more feasible way.

Published by Dec 25, 2024 Source :Business Next

Further reading

You might also be interested in ...

Headline
Market News
Engineering Plastics for 5G EMI Shielding and Thermal Control
The global rollout of 5G technology has been a catalyst for rethinking the materials used in next-generation devices. Unlike previous mobile generations, 5G relies heavily on millimeter wave (mmWave) frequencies, which offer faster data speeds but are more vulnerable to interference. With escalating demands for electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding and thermal regulation in compact, high-frequency environments, advanced plastics are becoming the backbone of 5G infrastructure. Taiwan manufacturers are engineering high-performance polymers that meet the complex requirements of these modern telecommunications.
Headline
Market News
Smart Labeling in Advanced Packaging Machines: Driving Traceability, Customization, and Efficiency
As packaging lines embrace greater automation and data integration, smart labeling has become a vital component of packaging systems. While AI vision systems enhance visual inspection and quality control, smart labeling technologies help manage data, ensure compliance, enhance traceability, and enable real-time customization in the packaging process.
Headline
Market News
Advanced Package Filling Machines with AI Vision Systems: A Modern Solution for Precision Packaging
Package Filling Machines integrated with AI Vision Systems offer advanced solutions for efficiently packaging food and powdered substances into precise, small-format packets. These food-grade systems combine mechanical precision with artificial intelligence to ensure quality, regulatory compliance, and high productivity.
Headline
Market News
Optical Lenses for AR/VR and Smart Devices: Taiwan’s Strategic Tech Advantage
As augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), and smart devices redefine how we interact with the digital world, one component lies at the heart of this transformation: the optical lens. These precision-engineered components enable everything from immersive simulations to advanced camera features and real-time data overlays. In this rapidly expanding sector, Taiwan has established itself as a strategic global hub for innovation, manufacturing, and partnership. With decades of expertise in optics, a robust high-tech supply chain, and strategic integration with the semiconductor and display industries, Taiwan is not only keeping pace with demand—it’s helping to shape the future of visual technology.
Headline
Market News
New Developments in 6G Infrastructure and Antenna Hardware
As the global race toward 6G intensifies, Taiwan is positioning itself at the forefront of next-generation wireless infrastructure and antenna hardware innovation. Building upon its robust semiconductor and telecommunications sectors, Taiwan is investing in advanced research and development to meet the demands of 6G, which promises ultra-high-speed connectivity, low latency, and seamless integration across diverse applications, from smart cities to autonomous vehicles.
Headline
Market News
Carbon Fiber Innovations: Lightweighting for Aerospace, Bikes, and Automotive Applications
Carbon fiber has become a key material in modern engineering, renowned for its exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance, and versatility. These properties make it indispensable in industries where performance and efficiency are paramount, such as aerospace, cycling, and automotive manufacturing. With its strong manufacturing base and innovation, Taiwan has emerged as a global leader in carbon fiber production.
Headline
Market News
Latest Advances in Solid-State Li-ion Battery Technology from Taiwan’s R&D Hubs
Solid-state batteries (SSBs) are set to have a massive impact on the electric vehicle (EV) market because they store more energy, charge faster, and are safer than standard liquid lithium-ion batteries. However, due to challenges such as material behavior, battery microstructure, short service life, and cracking caused by thermal expansion and contraction, their design still faces many obstacles. With major automotive and battery manufacturers competing to mass-produce SSBs for EVs, the global solid-state battery market is projected to grow from $85 million in 2023 to over $960 million by 2030.
Headline
Market News
The Rise of Digital Twins in Smart Manufacturing and Factory Design in Taiwan
Taiwan is rapidly emerging as a global leader in smart manufacturing, with digital twin technology at the forefront of this transformation. By creating virtual replicas of physical systems, digital twins enable manufacturers to simulate, monitor, and optimize operations in real time. This innovation is not only revolutionizing factory design, enhancing efficiency, and reducing downtime, but also fostering innovation across various sectors—opening new avenues for investment and business development in Taiwan’s industrial landscape.
Headline
Market News
Why Global Brands Are Investing in Taiwanese CNC and Precision Tooling Suppliers
As the global manufacturing sector regains momentum following recent supply chain disruptions and economic slowdowns, multinational companies are re-evaluating where and how they source their machinery. Taiwan—once viewed as a mid-tier supplier—is now emerging as a strategic investment destination for global brands seeking high-precision CNC machining, tooling innovation, and smart manufacturing integration. With projections of double-digit growth for 2025 following a temporary downturn, Taiwan’s machine tool sector is proving its resilience and global competitiveness. As demand for automation, customization, and advanced manufacturing solutions intensifies, more international buyers are shifting their attention - and capital - toward Taiwan’s CNC and precision tooling ecosystem.
Headline
Market News
Taiwan's Strategic Shift Toward Smart Manufacturing: Opportunities for Global Buyers and Local Innovators
As global industries increasingly embrace automation, digitalization, and sustainable production, Taiwan has emerged as a leader in this new wave of industrial transformation. Building on its strong foundation in traditional manufacturing—and accelerated by national initiatives like "Taiwan Industry 4.0"—Taiwanese manufacturers are rapidly upgrading their capabilities, creating exciting opportunities for both global buyers and local innovators.
Headline
Market News
3D Printers: Revolutionizing Prototyping and Manufacturing
3D printing technology has revolutionized the way industries approach manufacturing, especially when it comes to prototyping. Before its introduction, the process of creating prototypes was often time-consuming, costly, and resource-intensive. Traditional methods involved manual machining or molding, which required significant lead times and extensive human labor. With the arrival of 3D printers, designers and engineers found an efficient solution to rapidly create physical models from digital designs. This innovation allowed for faster iteration and improved communication between teams, ultimately speeding up the development cycle and reducing costs. Over time, 3D printing has not only enhanced prototype creation but has also expanded into full-scale manufacturing, enabling new possibilities for production across various industries.
Headline
Market News
The Technology and Features of Automatic Drip Coffee Makers
If you are a coffee lover, you surely know what an automatic drip coffee maker is. These machines have become a common sight in homes and restaurants alike, offering convenience and consistent quality. But have you ever thought about how these appliances came to be developed, and what technology actually powers them? You might find that the history, technology, and benefits of automatic drip coffee makers are quite interesting.
Agree